Peanut Butter Chocolate Popsicles with Greek Yogurt

Peanut Butter Popsicles are the BEST summer snack and one the kids go crazy for! This frozen peanut butter dessert has layers of chocolate too! Plus they’re made with Greek yogurt so you can feel good about getting extra protein!

I’m beyond excited that my kids are on summer break from school! Since my family lives on a farm, my kids go to work every day during the summer and I LOVE that!

Some days they are so busy that I hardly get a chance to see them. I do have my tricks for getting them to come home for a few minutes during the day.

I know if I tempt them with these Chocolate Peanut Butter Greek Yogurt Popsicles they will be home in a jiffy!

Ingredients in Greek Yogurt Popsicles

The ingredients you’ll need to make chocolate peanut butter Popsicles are simple! Here’s a rundown on what you’ll need!

• Greek Yogurt – Vanilla is best! You can use plain too, but it will be tangier unless you also add 2 Tablespoons of honey.
• Peanut Butter Chips- You could also use peanut butter too; creamy, chunky, whatever!
• Chocolate Chips – Milk chocolate, semi-sweet, or even chopped up candy bars
• Honey – Optional, but it really does make the yogurt pops sweeter, plus it’s a natural sweetener so you can feel good about it!

How to make Peanut Butter Greek Yogurt Popsicles Recipe

There are a few little tricks to making this Greek yogurt pops recipe! Some readers said the Greek yogurt mixture was lumpy before adding it to the popsicle molds. I’m going to walk you through it so they’ll make creamy Popsicle’s.

STEP 1: Add chocolate chips to a microwave-safe bowl. Microwave for one minute. Stir. If the chocolate isn’t completely melted microwave for 15 more seconds, then stir. Repeat until the chocolate is smooth. Set aside to cool until it’s still stirrable but cooled.

STEP 2: Add peanut butter chips to a microwave-safe bowl. Microwave for one minute. Stir. If the chocolate isn’t completely melted microwave for 15 more seconds, then stir. Repeat until the chocolate is smooth. Set aside to cool until it’s still stirrable but cooled.

STEP 3: Divide the yogurt in half and add half to each bowl of chocolate chips. Stir until smooth.

STEP 4: I like to add the Greek yogurt mixture to a sealable bag and snip one corner off then squeeze it into the molds. Mixture can also be spooned into molds.

STEP 5: Add a layer of peanut butter mixture to the molds. Top with a layer of chocolate mixture. Repeat twice more.

STEP 6: Tap molds gently on the counter top to knock the air bubbles out.

STEP 7: Freeze for 4-6 hours. The amount of time it takes to freeze the pops will depend on how big your molds are.

FAQs about Popsicles

• How long do Popsicles last in the freezer? At my house, they only last about 2 days before my boys eat all of them! They should last about 3 months!
• How to get Popsicles out of the mold? If it’s a plastic mold you can run the bottom under hot water for a minute then they should release.
• What kind of mold should I use to make Popsicles? Smaller molds are great for kids. I like the kinds with a stand.
• Can I make Popsicles if I don’t have a mold? If you don’t have popsicle molds you can use 3 oz. paper cups or plastic cups!

Easy Frozen Dessert Recipes

Frozen desserts are all the rage in the summer! We love frozen drinks, frozen pies, and all kinds of ice cream! Here is a few recipes I know you’ll love!

• Purple Cow Milkshakes – Skip the drive-through and make these three-ingredient milkshakes instead!
• Jello Milkshakes – Make any flavor of milkshake you like! Kids love this!
• Frozen Peanut Butter Banana Bites – A great healthy snack!
• Chocolate Greek Yogurt Bark – A healthy and fun breakfast!
• Brown Cow Ice Cream Floats – Icecream + chocolate milk
• Frozen Lime Pie – it will remind you of a mojito!
• No Churn Mint Ice Cream – loaded with mint and chocolate
• Strawberry Limeade – Like Brazilian lemonade
• Watermelon Lemonade – A great way to use leftover watermelon

Grab my Peanut Butter Popsicle Recipe

If you haven’t tried yogurt popsicles this is where you need to start! They are creamy, decadent, and even a bit healthy! Greek yogurt popsicle recipes might be your new summer treat!

Post was written in 2016 and updated in 2020.